The Columbus Suites · Est. 1890
89 Cottage Street, Middletown, NY 10940
89 Cottage Street is The Columbus Suites, the second building of The Columbus Hotel, a small owner-run hotel on one block of downtown Middletown, New York. 13 rooms, a kitchenette in each one, free parking, and a door that opens on a code at any hour.
The short answer
What is at 89 Cottage Street
89 Cottage Street is a hotel. It opened as The Hotel Neville in 1890, on the corner of Cottage & Prince Streets, and today it is The Columbus Suites, the second building of The Columbus Hotel. There are 13 guest rooms, each with a kitchenette and a private bathroom. You can book one for a night, a week, or a month. Free parking in the lot behind the building. Check-in is from 4:00 PM on a smart lock, so nobody has to be at a desk when you arrive. Mail and deliveries come to 89 Cottage St., Middletown, NY 10940. The Columbus Hotel is the other half of the same hotel, a short walk up the same street at 52 Cottage Street.
At a glance
The essentials at this address
- Address
- 89 Cottage Street, Middletown, NY 10940
- Mail and deliveries
- 89 Cottage St., Middletown, NY 10940
- What it is
- The Columbus Suites. 13 rooms, each with a kitchenette.
- Length of stay
- From a single night to twelve months, nightly, weekly, and monthly terms, with monthly rates on request.
- Check-in
- From 4:00 PM, smart-lock self check-in
- Checkout
- By 10:00 AM
- Parking
- Free parking in the lot behind the building.
- Getting in
- Two smart locks, one at the building entrance, one on your suite. Codes are sent on arrival day through your reservation messages.
- Building
- Walk-up, multi-suite buildings with stairs and no elevator. Shared, card-payment laundry on site.
On the map
Finding 89 Cottage Street
- Touro College of Osteopathic MedicineAbout a 9–10 minute walk from 52 Cottage; ~14 from 89.
- Paramount TheatreHistoric downtown theater, movies, concerts, and live shows, a short walk away.
- SUNY Orange (Orange County Community College)The downtown Middletown campus is close by.
- Garnet Health Medical CenterThe area's main hospital, a quick drive from both buildings.
- Clemson Bros. BreweryA short walk down Cottage Street for food, beer, and live events.
- Orange County Fairgrounds & SpeedwayFairs, expos, and seasonal events, minutes away by car.
Est. 1890
89 Cottage Street before it was ours
Mervin E. Pindar opened the Hotel Neville in 1890 for the railroad trade, rooms for commercial men and railroad crews near the Wickham Avenue depot. It later became the Hotel Lee.
Mervin E. Pindar · Cottage & Prince Streets
- 1890 Hotel Neville
- 1917 Hotel Lee
- 1961 Mary's Hotel
- Today, The Columbus Suites
Source: Middletown City Directory; building photographs by Peter Laskaris.
The other building
One hotel, two doors
The Columbus Hotel also runs The Columbus Hotel at 52 Cottage Street, a short walk up the same street. Same phone number, same booking, same house rules, same rooms. Free parking in the lot directly across the street.
52 Cottage St, Middletown, NY 10940Asked about this address
Questions
What is at 89 Cottage Street in Middletown, NY?
The Columbus Suites. 89 Cottage Street is The Columbus Suites, the second building of The Columbus Hotel, one of two buildings on Cottage Street run as one hotel. It was built in 1890 as The Hotel Neville, and it has 13 rooms available by the night, the week, or the month.
Can you rent an apartment at 89 Cottage Street?
Not on an ordinary residential lease. The rooms here are furnished and let as hotel stays, from a single night up to twelve months, with monthly rates on request. A stay of 30 nights or more may run under a separate occupancy agreement, so ask us about the terms before you book.
Is there parking at 89 Cottage Street?
Yes, and it is free. Free parking in the lot behind the building. It is first-come, first-served, one standard-size vehicle per reservation, and there is no charge and no permit.
How do you check in at 89 Cottage Street?
On a smart lock, from 4:00 PM, any hour of the night. There are two codes, one for the building entrance and one for your room, and they are sent on the day you arrive through your reservation messages. Checkout is by 10:00 AM.
Do the rooms at 89 Cottage Street have kitchens?
A kitchenette in every room, with a stove, a microwave and a full-size refrigerator. Some rooms also have an oven, but we do not promise one until we have checked yours, so plan on the cooktop.
Is The Columbus Suites the same hotel as The Columbus Hotel?
Yes. The Columbus Hotel runs both. 89 Cottage Street is The Columbus Suites and 52 Cottage Street is The Columbus Hotel, a short walk apart on the same street, with one phone number, one booking system, one set of house rules and the same rooms behind both names. Only the buildings are named differently.
What was 89 Cottage Street before?
Mervin E. Pindar opened the Hotel Neville in 1890 for the railroad trade, rooms for commercial men and railroad crews near the Wickham Avenue depot. It later became the Hotel Lee. 1890 Hotel Neville, then 1917 Hotel Lee, then 1961 Mary's Hotel, then restored.
What is the full mailing address for 89 Cottage Street?
89 Cottage St., Middletown, NY 10940. Written out in full it is 89 Cottage Street, Middletown, New York 10940. Both forms reach the same building, and so does 89 Cottage St, Middletown, NY 10940 without the period. There is no suite or unit line to add: mail and deliveries come to the street address.
Is there an elevator at 89 Cottage Street?
No. Both buildings are walk-ups with stairs. If that matters for your stay, message us before booking and we will help you find the best-fit room.
Something else about this address? hello@thecolumbushotel.com or (845) 474-2442.
Rooms at 89 Cottage Street, by the night or the month.
Browse the suites